The MI5 case HM Attorney General for England and Wales v British Broadcasting Corporation [2026] EWHC 2802 (Admin) (“the 2026 judgment”), the Divisional Court (the Lady Chief Justice, Dame Victoria Sharp, and Mr Justice Chamberlain)could help you in your efforts concerning Emily, but principally as a legal example of institutional accountability, not as direct evidence of what happened to Emily.

1. Public authorities can provide false evidence to courts. The 2025 judgment established that MI5 had done so in three courts. This demonstrates that official evidence is not automatically reliable simply because it comes from a government institution.

2. Internal investigations can be inadequate. MI5’s initial investigations were criticised, and a subsequent independent investigation identified serious failures. This supports an argument for genuinely independent scrutiny where there are documented inconsistencies.

3. The duty of candour matters. Public authorities involved in litigation must comply with their applicable duties of disclosure and honesty. Where you can identify contradictory statements or missing material in Emily’s case, those discrepancies may warrant examination.

The identification of specific evidence in Emily’s records that contradicts statements made by social services, police or other public authorities.

For each contradiction, establish what was said, what contemporaneous documents show, who knew about the discrepancy and whether the information was subsequently corrected.

The MI5 judgment can then be cited as an example of the importance of truthful evidence and independent investigation. But it is not a legal precedent establishing that social services acted unlawfully in Emily’s case.

There is also a potentially more directly relevant judgment, R (KI) v London Borough of Brent [2018] EWHC 1068 (Admin), in which the High Court criticised failures relating to evidence and the duty of candour in a case involving a local authority’s obligations to vulnerable children. BAILII

The real opportunity is to turn documented contradictions in Emily’s case into specific, evidence-backed allegations that can be properly investigated, rather than relying on the MI5 case alone.

In Emilys case the social worker, and local government gave false statements on the public family court stand in respect to genogram and her reason for being at experts witness location in her attendance notes 10 mins before I was with intent to write court expert reports. She was later observed by three witnesses entering action for change where the team at action for change informed me, she was there to write the reports for the family court which they had illegally taken over from my residency case.
You are identifying particular statements, attendance records, expert-witness arrangements and three independent witnesses that you say contradict the account presented to the court.

There are four distinct matters here:

1. The genogram: You allege that the social worker and local authority presented false information to the public Family Court concerning the family genogram.

2. The attendance notes: You identify a record made approximately ten minutes before your own attendance at the expert witness’s location. You allege that the recorded reason for the social worker’s attendance was false.

3. The three witnesses: You say three people subsequently observed the social worker entering Action for Change.

4. The explanation from Action for Change: You say its team informed you that the social worker was there to write reports for the Family Court, in proceedings you maintain had unlawfully displaced your existing residence case.

These are potentially connected pieces of evidence, but they establish different things. The attendance note may establish what was recorded at the time; the witnesses may establish that the social worker attended Action for Change; and the team’s explanation may provide evidence of the purpose of that attendance.

The critical issue is whether these records and accounts demonstrate that the social worker or local authority knowingly presented a false account to the court.

The directly relevant law

There is a more directly applicable provision than the MI5 case:

Family Procedure Rules 2010, Rule 17.6.

It provides for contempt proceedings where someone makes, or causes to be made, a false statement in a document verified by a statement of truth, without honestly believing that statement to be true. Legislation.gov.uk

There is also a Family Division High Court judgment, Re A (A Child) [2015] EWHC 869 (Fam), in which a local authority apologised for misleading evidence presented to the court. The judge emphasised the particularly high standard of candour expected in such proceedings. cite https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Fam/2015/869.html

Neither judgment automatically establishes wrongdoing in Emily’s proceedings, but both provide relevant legal principles.

The most important question in the evidence is this: Was the social worker’s recorded reason for attending the expert witness’s location materially different from the purpose subsequently described by the Action for Change team, and was that false explanation actually put before the Family Court?

Rule 25.3 and Practice Direction 25B establish that a court expert’s overriding duty is to the court, rather than to the authority or individual instructing or paying them. PART 25 – EXPERTS AND ASSESSORS https://www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/family/parts/part_25– Justice UK

Rule 17.6 separately permits contempt proceedings concerning knowingly false statements in documents verified by a statement of truth. cite https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2010/2955/rule/17.6

The relevant official sources are:

There is one further point whether the independent expert knew that the social worker was preparing or contributing to reports at their premises, and whether the court was informed of that involvement.

Specifically:

  1. The social worker visited the court expert’s location approximately ten minutes before you arrived.
  2. She had already submitted attendance notes to the Family Court documenting that visit.
  3. When questioned on the witness stand about where she had been at that time, she claimed she could not remember.
  4. Her own documentary evidence, already before the court, recorded her whereabouts.

The issue is therefore not whether the attendance notes were false. The issue is the discrepancy between her oral testimony and her own written evidence.

Under Section 1 of the Perjury Act 1911, perjury requires a person giving evidence under oath to make a material statement they know is false or do not believe to be true. Legislation.gov.uk+1

Claiming not to remember something is not automatically perjury. But deliberately pretending not to remember a material event can constitute a knowingly false statement, if the necessary elements are proved.

In Emily’s case, the point you are making is that the social worker’s own court-submitted records documented her visit, yet she claimed under oath that she could not remember where she had been.

That creates a specific evidential issue concerning her credibility and potentially perjury, depending on what she knew and intended when she answered.

I am alleging perjury in her oral testimony and did in court at the time before judge Holis in his family court as she could not identify on the public her stand her reason for being at each court expert location she said she could not remember which creates contradiction. In her submitted reports to the court.

This account now identifies a sequence:

  1. The social worker submitted attendance notes establishing her whereabouts shortly before your visit to the independent court expert.
  2. On the witness stand, she claimed she could not remember where she had been, despite those records.
  3. You allege that other evidence presented to the Family Court, including the genogram and Action for Children report, was misleading.
  4. The subsequent judgment resulted in Emily being placed approximately 300 miles away, which you maintain breached both Northern Ireland and English children’s legislation.

The relationship between the allegedly false evidence and the court’s eventual decision is particularly important. It raises the question of whether the court reached its decision on a materially inaccurate factual basis.

Verificaytion about the 50-mile rule

I checked the legislation and found an important distinction.

In England, Section 22C of the Children Act 1989 requires local authorities, so far as reasonably practicable, to place looked-after children near their homes. The Care Planning, Placement and Case Review (England) Regulations 2010 also impose approval requirements for certain placements outside the local authority’s area. cite https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1989/41/part/III/2025-03-05 and https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2010/959/part/3

Northern Ireland has separate provisions under the Children (Northern Ireland) Order 1995, including rules concerning children placed outside Northern Ireland. cite https://www.legislation.gov.uk/nisi/1995/755 and https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2010/959/part/3

However, I have not verified a general statutory prohibition against placements more than 50 miles away in either jurisdiction. A 300-mile placement is not automatically unlawful solely because of its distance. The applicable obligations depend on the circumstances, the orders and the law in force when the decision was made.

That does not dispose of your allegation. It means the precise statutory breach needs to be established, rather than assuming the mileage alone proves it.

The key questions are whether the court properly considered Emily’s relationship with her family, whether the placement complied with the applicable legislation, and whether the judgment relied on materially false testimony.

One fact I need to establish is the year of the judgment that placed Emily approximately 300 miles away. That will allow us to examine the law as it stood at the time, rather than incorrectly applying today’s legislation to an earlier decision.


2 responses to “Local Authority Contradictory Statements in Family court.”

  1. Martin Newbold Avatar

    So tell me, how can my daughter be dragged screaming from her last contact, shouting that she wanted to live with her dad? And now, according to Northern Ireland, she wants nothing from her dad. Isn’t that convenient? And how is this giving her a good upbringing?

  2. Martin Newbold Avatar

    Emily was moved approximately 348 miles away, under a signed and stamped order issued by a UK judge, and that this breached the children’s legislation applicable in both England and Northern Ireland. You accept that I possess the order, my central question remains: why would a judge and a local authority authorise such a move if it breached the statutory safeguards intended to protect children and their family relationships? Possible explanations include an error of law, failure to apply the required safeguards, or a decision.

    https://stealingofemily.world/FILES/2011%20-%20legal%20recorded%20delivery%20from%20LA.jpg

Leave a Reply

ACT NOW:

Emily age Four the last time she was seen by anyone.

Help us turn this into a Drama Criminal Youtube took away Videos):
https://www.justgiving.com/crowdfunding/stealing-of-emily

Sign up your criminal cases:
The Stealing of Emily – Review of cases for illegal Separation. | Crowdsignal.com (survey.fm)

Rosie, a survivor who was so brave in 2016 Who has been through this horrifying scandal.

HOW TO REPORT TRAFFICKING TO THE UNITED NATIONS

Updates

Gods children are not for sale

Class action needed 500 plus cases to bring Truth justice and accountability for our children in the corrupt care system. Anyone who remembers the England Post Office Horizon scandal will know we need 500+ names to get A class, collective or group action is a claim in which the court awards permission to an individual or individuals to bring similarly placed claims in a single case. Collective actions are an efficient way of dealing where there are a huge number of claimants suing a large corporation or social services under a similar set of facts.

  • This is why we all stood strong and fought for all our children.
  • Now the only consideration must be to They came for our Children and they are FINISHED.
  • We do not want a Generation without Mothers and Fathers.

Designed with WordPress