Title: Getting Away With Murder 2025

Authors: Martin Newbold
DOI: https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.29045015.v1
Published on: Figshare
Publication Date: 2025

Abstract:
This paper critically examines the use and consequences of Closed Material Procedures (CMP) within the family court system, specifically focusing on their impact on child safeguarding, family law, and transparency in judicial processes. Drawing on the real-life experiences described in The Stealing of Emily, the paper explores the legal framework, ethical concerns, and potential for misuse in secretive court procedures. It highlights the dangers of limiting transparency in cases where children’s lives are at stake, and the resulting erosion of trust in the judicial system. The paper calls for reform and greater accountability to ensure that the best interests of children are consistently protected.

Key Themes & Insights:

1. Closed Material Procedures (CMP):
   Analyzes the legal and procedural basis for CMP, where evidence is hidden from one party, potentially jeopardizing fairness and justice.
2. Child Safeguarding:
   Explores how CMP in family courts can undermine child welfare by prioritizing secrecy over transparency, which can have long-term consequences on vulnerable children and families.
3. Legal Reforms:
   Advocates for reform in the court system to balance transparency with security concerns, ensuring that children’s rights and familial integrity are not compromised in the name of “national security” or institutional convenience.
4. Real-Life Application:
   The paper incorporates insights from The Stealing of Emily, a book by the author, that highlights the personal and familial toll of navigating the covert aspects of legal proceedings in child protection cases.
5. Recommendations for Reform:
   Based on the findings, the paper suggests various reforms, including greater oversight of CMP and improved access to evidence for all parties involved in family court proceedings.

Keywords:

• Closed Material Procedures (CMP)
• Family Courts
• Child Safeguarding
• Legal Transparency
• Family Law
• Judicial Reform
• Children’s Rights
• Legal Ethics
• Court System Accountability

Link to Full Paper:
For detailed information and further discussion, access the full paper here:
2025-05-13 – Getting Away With Murder 2025.pdf